Pages

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Reading Prompt #7

According to Grgurović and Hegelhimer, subtitles and transcript are both very helpful to listening. But they also found that the subtitles are more frequently used than the transcript. That may because when one is doing listening practice, he or she tends to use help options which are more familiar to them in daily life, like subtitles. And higher lever learners are predisposed to subtitles which are written in the target language than those are written in the native language, while the lower level learners are the opposite. However, there are some failures of the participants to make use of the help options. The reasons may be degree of control or time pressure. If a participant cannot skip the help after comprehending the context or is forced to finish the task in a specified time, there’s no way he all she will be go through the subtitles or the transcript thoroughly. The authors point additionally that external factors such as motivation and attitudes towards the task could also be the reasons of the failures. Then turn to the SLA theory, we found that modified input would help to improve comprehension. Thus, the modification available in the form of subtitles and transcripts are important. The research in the paper shows that “All of the other groups that made use of input modifications demonstrated better learning gains overall”.

Among all the aspects the CALL book mentioned about practice, I most interested in pronunciation. Pronunciation is an important part of language learning. Unfortunately, because teach pronunciation require the language teachers have good pronunciation and in country like China, the rate between good language teachers and students is not reasonable, so it is impossible for teachers to give tutorial. That why apply CALL technology on pronunciation will be a great help for improving the students’ pronunciation and alleviate the teachers’ burden. For example, the students can have vivid learning experienced about producing specific sounds either in the shape of graphic annotations or through video and images, just like learning from the teachers. I want to teach Chinese in the future, so I hope the Chinese version of such technology will be widely used in Chinese learning.

3 comments:

Norma J - ESL 5073 said...

Ling, I agree with your summary of prompt 7. It was well written and now I understand more of it with your summary. I agree with subtitles. I often say that if only the Spanish channels would have subtitles, I could learn Spanish. They seem so interesting just by the body language alone. Have you heard of the Novellas., my sister watches them and she gives me the details. She knows more Spanish than I. I think that sometimes I often forget about the help features with any computer program. I tend to ask others for help and forget that I could have used the help features.

Jia You said...

Hi, Ling,
That’s a good response, and I agree with you that the subtitles as well as the transcripts can be regarded as effective modified input to enhance ESLs gaining language skills. And I personally like the subtitles, especially when I watch TV, I would like to use subtitles to catch the “flow” as well as learn new vocabulary and word usage. This helped me a lot. And I believe by using appropriate “help options”, ESLs can learn more and faster.

Ling said...

Thank you two, but I haven't finished my prompt yet...

Post a Comment